Desert
Specialty Underwriters, Inc.
Desert Specialty
Adjusters, Inc.
Employment Practices Liability
Q.:
What exposure does every employer have but few currently insure against?Q.:
Do I have an exposure?T F
o o
We have never terminated employee(s). We do not anticipate having to terminateo o
Our work force composition (race, ethnicity, gender, age) closely mirrors that of theo o
Our work force is regularly trained in acceptable behavior towards the opposite sex.o o
We have a written progressive disciplinary procedure.o o
We have no workers over the age of 40.o o
We have no employees with a disability (i.e., impaired hearing, obesity, alcohol oro o
We have women and minorities in executive/management role in the same proportiono o
We have never had a problem with an employee alleging unfair treatment.____ ____ TOTAL
Q.: What does it mean?
3 – 5 False answers
¾ You are a potential target for legal action by employees that may6 – 8 False answers
¾ You are a "high risk" employer for employment practices suits and shouldQ.: What exactly is the exposure?
A.: The exposure stems from employment practices, either real or perceived,
which may violate federal
or state laws, other regulations or societal standards. Examples:
·
Wrongful refusal to employ.·
Failing to promote.·
Wrongful termination.·
Sexual harassment.·
Discrimination for: race, color, creed, national origin, marital status, medical condition, gender,·
Defamation of character.·
Libel/slander.·
Invasion of privacy.·
Breach of implied contract.Q.: Is this exposure new?
A.: No, but legislation over the past 10 years, plus the visibility created
by the Clarence Thomas
confirmation hearings, and nearly continuous newspaper "headlines"
have increased public
awareness dramatically, resulting in skyrocketing numbers of claims.
Q.: How bad is it?
A.: Charges filed with the EEOC and corresponding state agencies for
employment cases has grown
by 50% from 1989-1997 to approximately 150,000 per year. The number of new
employment
discrimination lawsuits filed in state and federal courts is growing by over
20% a year, and is now in
excess of 70,000 per year – greater than the number of new product
liability suits filed annually!
Q.: Aren’t most losses small?
A.: Most, yes. But there are thousands of cases a year where large damage
awards/settlements are
made. Discrimination/harassment verdicts are now averaging over $800,000
each, for all
employers. Defense costs for such cases are averaging over $125,000-$150,000
for litigated
cases. Even when the amount of each loss in excess of $1 million is
eliminated, the average
plaintiff verdict is $324,000., plus defense costs.
Q.: Isn’t it only the large, public companies that are having the losses?
A.: No. Clearly, the larger companies make the
headlines. However, even the smallest of companies
have problems. While some federal laws only apply to firms above a certain size
(i.e., the Civil
Rights Act applies to firms above 15 employees), 37 states reduce this
threshold, some to as low
as one employee. Further, employers of all sizes are liable under common law for
charges of
negligence or intentional tort. Employers of less than 15 employees are
experiencing plaintiff
verdicts in employment discrimination cases that average $240,000 even after
removing the
amount of each judgment in excess of $1 million. Employers of between 50 and 100
employees
are averaging just over $300,000 per plaintiff verdict (after capping each at $1
million). Again,
these numbers are before the additional expense of defending oneself which is
averaging
$125,000-$150,000 per verdict, and before trying to calculate the value of the
time and effort spent
within the employer responding to such cases.
Q.: But don’t most cases settle before verdict?
A.: Yes, they do. Less than 5% of all lawsuits initiated actually go to
verdict. But of the remaining
95%+, those that receive settlements are averaging almost $50,000., with an
almost equal amount
spent on defense. Even cases for which lawsuits are never initiated, when
settled during the
administrative process of the EEOC or state agencies, are averaging awards of
almost $200,000.,
also with significant defense expenses required.
Q.: Don’t federal laws have damage caps?
A.: Some do, but not most. State laws have no such caps, and as a result, you
are exposed to
unlimited damages for most causes of action. Further, there is never a cap on
defense costs, or
under tort claims.
Q.: Isn’t there coverage under the GL policy, or other insurance policies?
A.: In absence of a specific exclusion, there may be a little coverage ¾
but not much. The Workers’
Compensation policy has a standard exclusion for these exposures under the
Employers Liability
coverage part. Commercial Umbrellas often exclude the exposure but without the
exclusion, only
provide very limited coverage. D&O policies may provide some coverage, but
unless endorsed,
usually do not extend coverage to the corporate entity, only to the individual
directors and officers.
Q.: Who qualifies for this insurance?
A.: Our product is designed for all your agency's current or prospective insureds.
Q.: Are there requirements to qualify?
A.: Yes. You must warrant that you will adopt within the first year of
coverage the minimum risk
management procedures we outline, if you do not already have them in place.
These procedures
and necessary forms/resources will be provided by us at no additional charge.
Q.: So what are the "negatives" from a buyer’s perspective?
A.: The following issues have been raised by potential customers in our market research:
1) Claims-made coverage form
Since the exposures in employment practices claims are volatile and dynamic,
the only way we
can provide coverage is on a claims-made form. Claims-made coverage applies to
losses for
which the claim against you is made during the policy period. This compares to
an occurrence
form provided for many insurance exposures which applies to losses which first
occur during
the policy period. We recognize that claims-made coverage may be new to many
insureds, but
it allows us to provide broader coverage and make it more affordable. Virtually
all writers of
EPLI do so on a claims-made form, which is typically used for all Errors &
Omissions and
Professional insurance. Your insurance agent can explain this and how it fits
your business.
2) Deductibles & Co-insurance
The establishment of a $5,000 minimum deductible was an essential element to
keep the
premium affordable for the small business. Higher deductibles can reduce
premiums. And you
can further reduce your premium by retaining a co-insurance percentage of each
loss which we
will cap at a fixed dollar amount for you.
These two features are also important to ensure that you remain a risk
management partner
with us, actively committed to implementing appropriate risk management/loss
control
procedures.
3) No coverage for Bodily Injury
While BI complaints are rare in these cases ("injury" is usually
economic or "personal injury"),
they should be covered by Workers’ Compensation or Health Insurance.
4) No coverage for Contractual Liability
The policy does cover those liabilities you have in absence of the contract.
However, if you
provide additional benefits or guarantees in a contract (individual or
collective), you must be
prepared to honor those promises.
Q.: And the positives?
A.: That’s the easy part. Wide-ranging risk management advice and
assistance which helps you create
and maintain procedures that reduce your exposures to loss, save time and money,
and help avoid
situations that can create bad feelings among employees, leading to low morale.
Further, this
information will help ensure that you are in compliance with applicable federal
and state laws.
·
Risk Management assistance is provided at no additional cost with this insurance, and·
Up to $1,000,000 of coverage.·
Broad coverage terms for the company and all employees for claims by an employee, former·
Defense of claims provided by experienced professionals.·
Low cost in relation to the protection and benefits provided.·
Options available (limits, deductible, etc.) to allow you to customize your coverage andQ.: So what’s the next step?
A.: Since no brochure can answer all your questions, contact DSU, Inc. for
more
information and request an application. The insurance coverage, and the risk
management tools
provided are important tools to help you better manage your business and protect
your assets. Let
us provide you more information, and a quote.